Purpose and Meaning

Ravings from the Frothy Middle


Blog For Free!


Archives
Home
2008 March
2007 August
2007 July
2007 February
2007 January
2006 September
2006 August
2006 July
2006 June
2006 May
2006 April
2006 March
2006 February
2006 January
2005 December
2005 November
2005 October
2005 September
2005 August
2005 July
2005 June
2005 May
2005 April
2005 March
2005 February
2005 January
2004 December
2004 November
2004 October
2004 September
2004 August
2004 July
2004 June
2004 May
2004 April
2004 March
2004 February
2004 January

My Links
Little Miss Attila
Dr. Forbush Thinks
Slashdot
Games Slashdot
User Friendly
James Randi
Snopes
Home of the Underdogs
The Sun Online

tBlog
My Profile
Send tMail
My tFriends
My Images


Sponsored
Blog


In which the middle-aged Peacenik mouths off about War Drones--and all the other things that make him cranky. Pnorny!

Mr Mahatma--who is a Mr in real life--lives in the valleys of Southern California with his wife, a herd of Dears, and an impressive collection of books. He is reachable at: littlemrmahatma@yahoo.com

All writings are copyrighted 2003-2008 and trademarked: Little Mr. Mahatma

Blogger Main Site


Still More Links:

Listed on BlogShares

Blogarama - The Blog Directory
Blogarama-Review My Site

IceRocket

LS Blogs

Blog Universe

Search For Blogs, Submit Blogs, The Ultimate Blog Directory

Blog Directory & Search engine

Site Meter


Purpose and Meaning
03.11.05 (12:48 pm)   [edit]
Yesterdays about Charles Townes post got me thinking about purpose and meaning in terms of religion. Townes states "If you look at what religion is all about, it's trying to understand the purpose and meaning of our universe..." But I think that's a loaded statement and here's why.


When you talk about a purpose of something, you imply that that something is a tool and therefore has a creator and/or user, and a goal to be achieved. What is the purpose of wind? You can't answer that - it's just wind. What's the purpose of a hammer? To hammer in nails for a job. Also, the hammer has a creator and a user. So by asking what is the purpose of our universe you imply an entity - in the common case, God - and a goal, an ending. But why does there have to be a purpose to our existence? What proof is there at all that our existence has a purpose? Science hasn't shown such a quality to our existence. This statement of purpose comes from the religious side and as such this statement is based on Faith - that is, without any support. Therefore you have to question why religion makes this statement of purpose. One answer could be as simple as "to keep religion in business", meaning that religion asks whether our existence has a purpose in order to justify a supreme entity and by circular reasoning to justify its own existence. "We believe that our existence has a purpose. This purpose is known to (our) God. Hence our religious attitude towards God is justified."


Worse, to have a purpose means to have a goal, an end, something to achieve. Religiion has had a field day determining what that is - ragnarok, nirvana, the ultimate after-armageddon party...


As an Atheist, I believe that our existence doesn't have a purpose - no Supreme Entity manipulating things behind the scenes. We're not participating in some galactic version of "The Sims". No, if our lives have purposes it's because of our own initiatives. And this holds for meaning. Our life's meaning is what we make of it, not because of some Supreme Entity whose messages have to be interepreted by a privileged preacher class, but what we choose. If we decide to spend our lives blogging and playing video games then so be it if we're content and not hurting any one. If what gives our lives meaning is to travel or to have kids then so be it as long as we accept responsibility for our lives.


If anything, Townes is too ivory-tower about religion. Inside academia, religion may be about deep philosophical questions but outside of academia, religion is about power - controlling the flock to maintain and expand it's own existence. Religion is about money. You go to near any poor part of the world and what will you find amidst the starvation - a church or some religious building. Sure, some of them bring food but they are there for presence, to bring "hope" and by bringing "hope" to maintain control and don't forget to give to the passing plate. There aren't many churches that you can attend for free on a consistent basis.


Crap, another rant! Look, you want meaning and purpose - go outside and look up, look down, look at your neighbor. Smile, breathe, laugh, sing. Hug your kids, your dog, your in-laws. Chill out, warm up, grow up, keep the child within. Learn, experiment, sleep. In short, live a life and enjoy it.

 


posted by: ESLjinju (reply)
post date: 03.11.05 (3:30 pm)

kidly visit my blog.. http://esljinju.tblog.com and open the FORUM.. please i badly needs replies there.. thanks a lot



posted by: DrForbush (reply)
post date: 03.11.05 (3:32 pm)

I like your idea that assuming a purpose imply's a creator. I never looked at the problem that way before. Did you think of it yourself, or is it a philosophical answer from another great thinker? :-)

Thanks.



posted by: LynnKramer (reply)
post date: 03.14.05 (12:49 pm)

As an atheist, what purpose do you have to your life other than as a consumer? You calculated how much dung you have produced since your birth, is that the sum of your existence?



posted by: littlemrmahatma (reply)
post date: 03.15.05 (7:15 am)

Dr. Forbush - I came up with that one all by my lonesome.

Lynn Kramer - Who says life HAS to have a purpose? Since you appear to hold that life does have a purpose, what do you show to support your claim?

Your Name:


Your Comment:


More Links:

POLITICS:
Arianna
FactCheck.ORG not .COM
SpinSanity
Black Box Voting
OpenSecrets
Open The Government
AntiWar
Americans United for Separation of Church and State
Church of Critical Thinking
The New Enlightenment
Mother Jones
Reuters
Pravda

RELIGION:
Secular Web - Atheism
Skeptic's Annotated Bible and annotated Koran.
The Happy Heretic
Fallacies
The Skeptic's Dictionary
God of the Month
Religion Selector